
A One Mann’s Movies review of “A Talent For Murder”. (2026, 3*, 15).
Seen as a preview, A Talent For Murder opens in cinemas in the UK on Friday. It’s a curious beast, with much that I can praise about it. However, its story arc (or lack thereof) left me curiously disappointed.
One Mann’s Movies Rating:


Plot:
Edward Ridgeway (Alden Ehrenreich) works for a US publisher and travels to Switzerland to try to persuade the reclusive, cranky and ‘blocked’ author Patricia Highsmith (Helen Mirren) to write a sixth Tom Ripley novel. As he tries to provide Highsmith with inspiration he populates her ideas with the beautiful and mysterious girl – Clementine Balfour (Olivia Cooke) – that he met on the train, and fact and fiction become increasingly merged.
Certification:
UK: 15; US: R. (From the BBFC website: “strong sex, violence, language.”)
Talent:
Starring: Helen Mirren, Alden Ehrenreich, Olivia Cooke, James Faulkner, Juliet Stevenson, Brid Brennan.
Directed by: Anton Corbijn.
Written by: Joanna Murray-Smith.
Running Time: 1h 45m.

Review:
Positives:
- Acting-wise, the leads are great.
- Helen Mirren, made up to look like a leathery old prune, is wonderfully irascible as Patricia Highsmith: reflecting the woman in her old age, who I have read was renowned for being cranky, deeply misanthropic, and frequently outrageous in both her social behavior and personal views. Mirren’s timing in delivering her lines is pitch-perfect.
- It is also great to see Alden Ehrenreich back on the screens in a leading role again. It looked like, after Hail Caesar, that he might grow into a major star. But after a disappointing turn as Han Solo in Solo: A Star Wars Story, seen as a the first Star Wars box office flop, his career seemed to get derailed. He had parts in films like Cocaine Bear, Oppenheimer and Weapons, but they were far from being leading roles. Here he is very good, particularly in one scene where the camera has a close up of him morphing from one ‘character’ into another.
- Making up the triplet of stars is Olivia Cooke (Pixie; Sound of Metal; Ready Player One) who makes a hugely attractive impression as the dream girl of Edward in real life and the ‘mark’ for Ripley in the literary world. Cooke has a wonderful ‘girl next door’ feel about her: she always strikes me as a younger version of Rachel McAdams in that regard. Eminently watchable.
- Acting nods also to Juliet Stevenson as Clementine’s Aunt Peggy and Brid Brennan as her friend
Kathryn Grierson, providing wise advise to Edward in a very entertaining scene.
- The film cleverly weaves together real-life with the book that the pair are developing, leaving me now – thinking back about the film – trying to unpick in my mind which bits were real and which bits were not. Most of the book recreations are beautifully done, well filmed and paced: who doesn’t love a Ripley-powered murder-mystery? Some of the scenes also made me want to go back to Rome for a visit!
- Robbie Ryan is the DP, and the Swiss countryside looks magnificent. There are some lovely external drone shots of Edward/Clementine’s train winding through the Swiss countryside.
- The Production Design involved in Highsmith’s apartment is superb: as Edward climbs the stairs and enters the ‘holy-of-holies’ – her office – he says “Wow!” and, as the audience, so do we.
- The film has a nicely noirishly intriguing score by Dickon Hinchliffe.
Negatives:
- The film has a very unconventional story-arc which really involves an almost schizophrenic morphing of Edward’s character with that of Tom Ripley. But as the end-titles came, it made me think “is that it”? Because although the film had many things for me to like about it, the whole concoction ultimately felt quite insubstantial and hollow.
- The illustrious Mrs Movie Mann had an issue with the sex scenes in the film – a submissive woman and an overly dominant man – which, she said, felt like a throwback to a film of the ’70s or ’80’s: . (When the first title came up at the end as “Directed by Anton Corbijn” she muttered, “I knew it – a man”). I see where she’s coming from with that. I guess the book version of the sex scene might be justified, since the Ripley books were written between 1955 and 1991. But we reenact the scene in ‘real-life’, with the addition of a knife. In general, I wasn’t convinced that Clementine was ‘that type of girl’: or was assertive enough to suddenly come out with the phrase to Edward “When were you going to fuck me?”.

Summary Thoughts:
This is an odd one, since my positives far outweigh the negatives in terms of number. But my rating really reflects that fact that on coming out, neither myself or the Illustrious Mrs Movie Man felt that we would recommend seeing this film to our friends.
Where to watch?
Trailer
The trailer for the film is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IzFgGhFrx0o.
Subscribe
Don’t forget, you can subscribe to One Mann’s Movies to receive future reviews by email right here. No salesman will call!